Brett Favre has the most experience. Peyton Manning is also a good quarterback. Manning is a choke artist in the playoffs. And he fails anytime he's up against a good defense (its been proven in the playoffs before). I'd rather have Tom Brady over either of them, but between the two I would go with Brett Favre.
Terry Crow - 14 years ago
Peyton Manning is head and shoulders above the rest of this bunch. Ask yourself what the results of the season would be if, say Brett Favre had been the quarterback for the Jets, Drew Brees had been the QB of the Vikings and Mark Sanchez had been the leader of the Colts. Or any other combination of teams and quarterbacks that you can think of. Manning is the best of the recent quarterbacks, taking into consideration the rules of today's game which greatly favor the offense.
Brett Favre has the most experience. Peyton Manning is also a good quarterback. Manning is a choke artist in the playoffs. And he fails anytime he's up against a good defense (its been proven in the playoffs before). I'd rather have Tom Brady over either of them, but between the two I would go with Brett Favre.
Peyton Manning is head and shoulders above the rest of this bunch. Ask yourself what the results of the season would be if, say Brett Favre had been the quarterback for the Jets, Drew Brees had been the QB of the Vikings and Mark Sanchez had been the leader of the Colts. Or any other combination of teams and quarterbacks that you can think of. Manning is the best of the recent quarterbacks, taking into consideration the rules of today's game which greatly favor the offense.