Who's your favorite <i>Star</i> judge?

16 Comments

  • angie spell - 11 years ago

    who in the world chose alton and giada as judges for this contest! alton is so off the wall i just do not watch
    his shows at all. giada with her "purrfect" and "aaaand" drives me crazy! The men probably like to watch
    her since she tries to show her boobs!

  • shelley - 11 years ago

    What on earth is with Giada?!? She keeps making nasty faces and is coming off like a nasty little snot. Then, in the next set she is all smiley and cutesy. I have always thought she was fake-acting, but now more than ever!

  • Melinda Shaum - 11 years ago

    Alton is my all time fav, second only to Julia Child! He knows more about food, food trivia, and food misc. than anyone on the planet, plus he is just plain cool! Bobby Flay is my next fav- very professional, funny, easy to talk to but knows his stuff. Both represent FN very well. I watch these two chefs in anything they do. Giada- she is unapproachable, comes off fake, better than everyone else and I don't watch her shows. I don't tink she would win a Next Food Network Star contest. Rachel or Melissa would do such a better job. Dump Giada!

  • Mari - 11 years ago

    Watched the Next Food Network star (4th of July) episode. I can't believe that Giada was commenting on what the contestants were doing wrong! I remember watching the Thanksgiving live broadcast last year, Giada made a fool of herself not taking anything seriously. She didn't cook what she was supposed to cook. She was drinking,probably drunk! That was really unprofessional. She comes across as a very hypocritical person. I don't think is is an asset to the show. I say fire her & bring back Paula.

  • your mom - 11 years ago

    Giada is annoying. Bobby seems pretty arrogant. I dont think Paula Deen should have been dropped from the Network for telling the truth in court for something she said 20-whatever- years ago. I am sure everyone has said something they are not proud of

  • Guest - 11 years ago

    I seriously can't believe you booted Paula from your Network for something that stupid. People are overly sensitive in this day and age and really need to stop playing the damn race card all the time. What's even more stupid is a person tried to sue Food Network for a comment Paula never made because "they were offended". Americans have a bad reputation for being "sue happy". That just made me lol for the sheer stupidness of it all. I mean seriously, wtf is wrong with you people? Paula was my favorite host on FN. She was the most down to earth and personable person on the whole damn network. Susie, you're an arrogant bitch. And Bobby, you're a complete and utter douchebag in every respect of the word. I will no longer be watching Food Network.

  • Elizabeth - 11 years ago

    I used to hate Giada, but then when I saw her last season on Star, her compassion and encouraging attitude she had for her team really touched me and she didn't come off as fake at all. As for Bobby, I can't and never will stand him. He always comes off as a major douche bag no matter what show he's on. I really don't like his "I'm better than you" attitude. Alton is cool. His humor makes the show more entertaining.

  • Mburas - 11 years ago

    I would like to say first of all i love food network! I find it very discriminating against Paula Deen to fire her for a lawsuit that a money hungry person filed against her and she never used racial slurs on shows on ur network yet when Bobby Flay takes God's name n vain on his show on ur network which offends many Christians u do nothing to him or others that do offensive things on their shows! Food for thought for U producers

  • Lori - 11 years ago

    Elton Brown is my favorite Food Network Chef. His culinary expertise and sense of humor combine to make him respected and enjoyed by not only myself, but by everyone I know. His recipes always come out perfectly. It is obvious he is the consumate professional who has the ability to make cooking informative and fun.

  • Rosa - 11 years ago

    i love the Food Network and always will. i love the three judges but Alton is my fav, he reminds me of a favorite uncle. i love Bobby and Giada also and love them as judges please keep them. I love the Star Salvation online also with Robert. ok i love all of Food Network Stars. My tv is constantly on that channel and never will change.

  • aiden nathaniel - 11 years ago

    paula deen firing was engineered by bobby flay, bob tusch, and suzy frizz hair all of food network star who hate all southerners. they have expressed hatred for the southerner ms deen also trisha yearwood whom won a daytime emmy award for trishas southern kitchen. send your comments to those three dumb asses. the deen controversy was schemed by the three to rid the network of paula deen , whose contract expires on june 30th. coincidence i think not. you be the judge

  • Ruth Galt - 11 years ago

    I have watched Food Network since the beginning, it's always on. Even though I like most of the programs, after what you did to Paula I will no longer be watching and I know a lot of my friends will no longer be watching, we have been discussing it. While you are free to fire whomever you wish, we have the option not to watch your network.

  • karen - 11 years ago

    I'm sorry, but Giada seems egocentric. Bobby and Alton are so relaxed and approachable.

  • bart abbott - 11 years ago

    My tv Never turns from Food Network.. after what you did to Paula.. ill nevever watch another one of your shows.. you should be ashamed.. so long forever..

  • Tz - 11 years ago

    A pretty face and an iron chef can't beat the good eats man!

  • Brad - 11 years ago

    Giada is the hottest be far

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment