Did America get it right?

Even though i wanted Syesha to make it to the top 2...I feel the losers will do better professionally than the winner. They will be able to show their true talent without being told what and how to sing. Syesha will go a long way!!!!!!!

It is unfortunate that mostly the teens are deciding who moves on. Since when do teens know anything especially with musical talent? I know they are the ones that will buy the albums but do we really need the young David "are-whatever" making an album of ballads that don't even sound good? Let's just hope he isn't the American Idol winner. Why is he even a heartthrob with the teenie girls he looks like he is 12 maybe 13 with a persona to match!

All though all 3 finalists are great singers and they will all do very well in the business, I believe that they got the voting wrong by sending Syesha home as my idea of an IDOL is the whole package and not just vocals. Syesha has all of the credential to be the American IDOL, vocals, performance, looks and most of all she can sing all different kinds of music, where the others either stick with ballads & love songs or rock.

The only reason I say they got it right is because of the fact that I knew, from the get-go, that it was gonna be the 2 Davids. And for those that say David Archuleta shouldn't be there, he actually does have major talent, especially for his young age. Now, why he is not my personal choice to win, I predict he will, due to the fact that most voters are girls age 12-17. I'd rather have David Cook win, but either way it doesn't matter. All of the ton 10 will end up with a career somewhere.

WAY TO GO THE 2 DAVIDS. I KNEW THAT YOU TO WOULD MAKE IT. You both have wonder voices. see you next week. GOOD LUCK

I wish the best for both Davids. I like Cook, but I am definetly for Archuleta. He is the bomb. Just because he sings ballads better than faster songs, doesn't mean that he's boring. He was a little predictable, but I kept my eyes on this season because of him. I always had that wonder of what song he was going to sing and how well he was going to sing it and what the judges would say. Everyone says that he was predictable, but David Cook was more predictable than him. What kills me, is that everyone says that Archie needs to mature up, but no one said anything about Jordin Sparks last year. She was only 17. Maybe Archie can have a nice R&B career, because he has the soul in his voice. That's the thing that he has over Cook. He can sing anything, whether it be country, rock, or soul. David Cook is just rock. So, go DAVID ARCHULETA. I HOPE YOU WIN AND I WILL BE VOTING 100 TIMES JUST TO TRY TO MAKE SURE THAT YOU DO.

I will tell you who will win American Idol and why. It will be David Archuleta. He will win for 2 reasons. 1) He's young and the little girls are screaming for him because he suppose to be cute and 2) American Idol set it up based on that fact, they're convince that makes records. I doubt he will get far. I have watched A.I. since it aired ,it was a good show in the begining. Now it's ruled by kids who don't know talent when they see cute boys. Here's an example SanGia. I will not watch the final show or any other time. Jennifer Hudson got away with an oscar. She has talent. Enjoy the show KIDDIES.

I you read Jennifer's comment. I proved my point.

I think america got it right Sayesha I hope I spelled her name right is gping to do just fine I have a feeling that Andrew LLoyd Weber is going to ask to do some broadway. She does have a wonderful voice and wish her the best. But now its on to the Davids this were the fun begins. America is going to have a tuff time on this one I wonder if for the first time on American Idol they would have to choose both Davids because for the first time this has to be the hardest choice in American Idol History. Good luck to both.