Who gave the best performance of the night? (Poll Closed)

I really think that Brook, sadly, will be leaving us. She has the lowest number of votes on dialidol....I know they aren't always correct, but I just have a feeling. I certainly hope not. She didn't do great tonight, but I just love her.

Brooke seems to always have problems and she's fading ino the wallpaper for me. Go David Cook Kanas City Represent!!!! W00T!!!

I think the bottom 3 tonight will be Carly, Brooke and Kristy. I hope Carly fans will vote a lot tonight because Simon literally threw her under the bus! I think Brooke will go home based on tonights performance. Kristy stepped up a notch from her previous engagement so I think she's good for another week. Bye Bye Brooke!

Btw, the boys gave a MARVELOUS Performance tonight! Way the go boys! I think it will be a DAVID COOK-DAVID ARCHULETA finals! Now that my favorite Michael Johns is out of contention, David Cook holds the spot!

Rickey, what will I do without your site every night? Thks! Try this, everybody: just listen to all 7 audios, one by one. No videos, just once. Then, make a choice. Most of you will definetely agree with me. Best voice and touching performance: DAVID ARCHULETA. And he is ONLY 17! David Cook? Very good performer, not that good voice. Syesha and Carly? Only big voices. Jason Castro? Good only if you watch him. Kristy? Improving, surprising. Brooke? Showed it all, bye and thanks.

If we talk about performance, the bottom 3 should be Brooke, Kristy & Jason. However, fans seem to be deaf. Brooke should go. She sounded like she is reciting a poem towards the end of her song.

If we talk about performance, the bottom 3 should be Brooke, Kristy & Jason. However, fans seem to be deaf. Brooke should go. She sounded like she is reciting a poem towards the end of her song.

If we talk about performance, the bottom 3 should be Brooke, Kristy & Jason. However, fans seem to be deaf. Brooke should go. She sounded like she is reciting a poem towards the end of her song.

I know brooke white gave her best performance tonight carly smithson as well I hope you in this night

Unfortunately I think Carly will go home, though I think she did awesome on her song (brought me to tears)...the public doesn't seem to like her for some reason. On the converse, Brook, who in my opinion has been like watching a wet rag dry the entire season, and who, also in my opinion, couldn't sing her way out of a wet paper bag, is loved by the public...why I don't know...she's such a flake. So she'll probably stay (much to my chagrin). Of the guys, the only one I like is Jason. David C's a schmuck and David A's a robot. Can David A sing...yes, but only power ballads...BORING! Can David C perform? Yes, but his singing is hit and miss. Can Jason perform? Not in the way that most Americans seem to like, but his singing is unique and he's always a joy to watch. Go Jason! You're the most interesting of the ones left...except for maybe David C and Carly, but I can't vote for a schmuck and I can't waste Jason votes on a lost cause! (As for Kristy, she did awesome on her song last night...ticked me off that the judges didn't seem to agree. I'm not a huge Kristy fan, but I do agree that she's a smart girl who makes smart choices.)

Oh, btw, not that anyone cares, but if the finale is between the Davids...I won't be watching. How boring is it that we pretty much already know who the top two will be and who will win. *yawn*

go david and david they are both brilliant!!!!!!

Just to let you know, that arrangement was not originally David Cook's. So was the Billie Jean and so is every arrangement he has performed since the beginning, except for the Dolly Parton one. They are arrangement from indie artists and he's taking credit for them. :S

Jason was the best last night. He gets better every week! He has an emotional connect with the audience, and he knows who his audience is. He knows how to tell a story with song. Randy does not want Jason to win. He wants Kristy to win because she's the American Idol "Template". Jason is shaking up the dynamics of the competiton. He's got definite style. Even if he doesn't take the title, he will be a super star.