I think the whole show should go. I am tired of American Idol blah blah blah. For Two nights a week my family sites around the tv watching people sing I am just tired of hearing it.
Anna - 13 years ago
J-Lo needs to go. I was not pleased with her judging and feel that she favored the females over the males. I also did not care for her pouty attitude when her favorite(s) were voted off! And no, she should not have been the most beautiful woman......that should have gone to Kate Middleton by far.
Mindy - 13 years ago
I think that the judges were way better than years past. I found american idol way more entertaining.
Roger Gambill - 13 years ago
I am 64 years old, and have watched idol from the beginning. Randy for the most part has always been fair in the past, but this year he clearly lets his pick be known. This is wrong, and great example of this is the way he treated Haley this year. It was real clear that he wanted her voted off. He loved Casey and James two that I was glad to see leave. I believe Randy has been there long enough. Also do away with the judges having one save. That is a slap in the face of the voters.
Lisa - 13 years ago
I'm ready for new judges. This year kinda bored me with the judging panel and some of the judging was just rediculous in my oppinion and I kept thinking, Gosh, I miss Simon." I voted to let all 3 therefore GO. I'd perfer fresh judges. I miss Paula too. This is an entertainment show and Simon and Paula were very entertaining and enjoyed hearing them unlike this seasons judges. I'm ready for X Factor!
Jim Craig - 13 years ago
Steven should not bebrought back, this is very much a family show and his actions as well as language is not what most parents want their children to see and hear. He takes away from the show as a whole.
Susan - 13 years ago
This was the best Idol season ever. I've watched all of them and these judges absolutely without a doubt picked the best Hollywood Week and final 11 lineup ever on the show. It would be a real shame to lose any of them because they ALL know what they are doing. Even Simon said the show was better this year than ever before.
Barbara - 13 years ago
I agree with Marc. This has been the best season EVER! Idol has never had a more talented group of contestants and Jennifer, Steven and Randy made it perfect. I sure hope they all come back next year!! simon who?
Rusty - 13 years ago
Where's the who cares selection button. I am so sick of reality TV I could hurl.
Marc - 13 years ago
Jennifer gives the show a warmth and tenderness. I think she works well and compliments the guys. It would leave a big hole if she were to leave. This was by far the best season ever. Why would you want fix it if it ain't broken?
Deb - 13 years ago
I love JoLo and loved her husband Marc Anthony, but was very disappointed in Marc's performance last night. It is "American Idol" not "Hispanic Idol"
I think the whole show should go. I am tired of American Idol blah blah blah. For Two nights a week my family sites around the tv watching people sing I am just tired of hearing it.
J-Lo needs to go. I was not pleased with her judging and feel that she favored the females over the males. I also did not care for her pouty attitude when her favorite(s) were voted off! And no, she should not have been the most beautiful woman......that should have gone to Kate Middleton by far.
I think that the judges were way better than years past. I found american idol way more entertaining.
I am 64 years old, and have watched idol from the beginning. Randy for the most part has always been fair in the past, but this year he clearly lets his pick be known. This is wrong, and great example of this is the way he treated Haley this year. It was real clear that he wanted her voted off. He loved Casey and James two that I was glad to see leave. I believe Randy has been there long enough. Also do away with the judges having one save. That is a slap in the face of the voters.
I'm ready for new judges. This year kinda bored me with the judging panel and some of the judging was just rediculous in my oppinion and I kept thinking, Gosh, I miss Simon." I voted to let all 3 therefore GO. I'd perfer fresh judges. I miss Paula too. This is an entertainment show and Simon and Paula were very entertaining and enjoyed hearing them unlike this seasons judges. I'm ready for X Factor!
Steven should not bebrought back, this is very much a family show and his actions as well as language is not what most parents want their children to see and hear. He takes away from the show as a whole.
This was the best Idol season ever. I've watched all of them and these judges absolutely without a doubt picked the best Hollywood Week and final 11 lineup ever on the show. It would be a real shame to lose any of them because they ALL know what they are doing. Even Simon said the show was better this year than ever before.
I agree with Marc. This has been the best season EVER! Idol has never had a more talented group of contestants and Jennifer, Steven and Randy made it perfect. I sure hope they all come back next year!! simon who?
Where's the who cares selection button. I am so sick of reality TV I could hurl.
Jennifer gives the show a warmth and tenderness. I think she works well and compliments the guys. It would leave a big hole if she were to leave. This was by far the best season ever. Why would you want fix it if it ain't broken?
I love JoLo and loved her husband Marc Anthony, but was very disappointed in Marc's performance last night. It is "American Idol" not "Hispanic Idol"