Who gave the best performance of the night? (Poll Closed)

All the people who voted for David A. as the best performer of tonight deserve to be slapped with a large, cold mackerel.

Ok, so David A wasn't the best tonight.. But quite entertaining.. JP, why you even want to slap the voters anyway? Hahahaha..

It is going to get interesting. I think only a few of them are actually safe.

I love Amy. I hope she stays on for at least a few more weeks.

Cook was the best.I didn't care much for Brooke's Let it be.Last week I thought she was best,but for me,this had her back at average.Kristy has been riding the next to last spot for 2 weeks and this week she falls off the horse into the mud.Hernandez could be in bottom 2 or it could be that other waiting to be voted off Chikezie. That's my 2 centavos...

I'd rather see Kristi stay than Brooke...I can't STAND her! UG...she has no appeal to me. Does the same ole thing every week, has NEVER performed and is just dull and dry week after week. Of course my favorite, Jason, is starting to get that way too...predictable. C'mon man...surprise us! I know you have more than that...let's see it. The music industry needs your originality...so pep it up some!

Jennifer it shows a lack ofintellect on your part to say that Brooke is dry and dull every week. Why do you think the pro's (the judges) keep saying she's the best performer for 3 weeks straight now? It's because there's a lot more that gopes into a performance than if you like the person. She is one of the most talented ones in the competition and I agree with TVguide.com that says she's the pick to win it all.

How on earth did 200+ people vote for David A? Does he have a really big family or something? If you have any objectivity at all, there is no way a performance with several flubbed lyrics counts as the best of the night.

David dropped a mega bomb last night, which was inevitable. His fans will see him through but I don't see anything in him. His lip licking and breathing are all turn offs. His being on just because will ruin the season for me.

Amanda Overmyer will go home tonight - David Cook or Ramiele will win it all

I think Amanda will at least make the final 4. Just my opinion.