Fourth Judge: Who do you like so far? (Part 2) (Poll Closed)

Katy Perry? Really? I don't think she should have the right to judge other people's live singing since she can't sing live herself.

Neil Patrick Harris :D

I think Shania Twain would make an awesome judge. Plus she is an awesome/amaing singer and very talented.

@Jay who says Paula, Randy, Simon or Kara can sing well live? You don't have to be able to sing live in order to judge people. I can't sing, but I can hear who did well and who didn't.

I guess you're right, but also, I just don't think that she will make a good judge. SAme with Joe Jonas, they just don't seem like the American Idol judge type, you know I mean?

Neil Patrick is a perfect balance between Randy, Kara and Simon...He brings
a lot of epxerience in many areas of the entertainment fields to the show. I think he would continue to be really a good influence on the show and it's continued popularity without Paula...He's got some "heart" too...like Paula..