4 Comments

• 
  Dave Reid - 15 years ago

  Departed is a pretty good movie but there is no way should it have been best picture. It is the worst best picture, and it is the worst Scorsese picture

• 
  Shamspade - 15 years ago

  American Beauty for worst, Mulholland Drive for best. Mullholland Drive is one of the few movies that can justifiably be called a work of art. It transcends its medium and transforms it at the same time. I can't think of another story told by the subconscious images of an unconscious "narrator", let alone a story told so powerfully and truthfully. Genius.

• 
  Roger - 15 years ago

  1985 Best Picture should have been Witness.

• 
  alofarabia - 15 years ago

  The worst Best Picture of the last 40 years has to be American Beauty.