Answers Logo
Search


Should States pass legislation requiring schools retire Indian mascots?



Yes

No

Vote

Share/Save/Bookmark
View The Results of This Poll



rss
138 Comments
Caleb Chvala
2009-03-13 15:47:59 ET

MWF 10 AM I think that legislation would set a bad precedent for government control of freedom of speech issues. That being said, I think it is very sad that legislation has to be considered in deterring Indian mascots. I am not Indian, but I have always found Indian mascots to be offensive. The fact that schools are close-minded to solutions based on tradition and how things were in the past is upsetting.

Jessica Collins
2009-03-13 16:05:28 ET

MWF 10:00 native american studies class

Sean D Blocher
2009-03-13 16:57:51 ET

MWF 10:00 NA

Charles Nielson
2009-03-13 17:03:08 ET

MWF 1:00

Rachael Urkoski
2009-03-13 17:40:57 ET

MWF 9:00---I believe that Indian mascots are offensive, but I think passing legislation to get rid of Indian mascots would just cause more anger and frustration to those parties who are fully against it. I don't believe legislation is the right away to solve this issue!

Lu Hug
2009-03-13 17:47:50 ET

For the most part, we have the right to say, do, think what we want in this country, and for the most part that is good. I don't think ANYONE wins when we confuse legality with morality.
10am MWF

Kim Woodward
2009-03-13 18:54:32 ET

MWF 9:00

Kim Woodward
2009-03-13 18:54:55 ET

MWF 9:00

Miko Koricic
2009-03-13 19:39:05 ET

MWF 10am, I agree that indian mascots are offensive. I am croatian, and irish, im not offended when I see the fighting irish or leprechauns. That being said, Indians mascots seems to be overly dramatized and offensive.

Lara Cobleigh
2009-03-13 19:42:51 ET

MWF 10:00

Andric Hofrichter
2009-03-13 20:53:04 ET

I agree with Caleb Chvala in that I really don't like the idea of the government passing legislation to ban such a thing. I don't find those mascots all that offensive personally, because I don't have any background in the area. However, I can see how they could and would be offensive to those who come from an Indian background. Hence, I think the schools should stop, but the government should definitely not get involved.

Erica Anderson MWF 10am
2009-03-13 21:22:36 ET

Forcing people to do something won't allow them see to the reason for the change.

Katie Weis
2009-03-14 00:09:27 ET

MWF 10:00

That's the only way that they would get schools to change.

Paul Irvine
2009-03-14 00:58:56 ET

MWF 10:00 People in hillbilly Nebraska will never change.

Kirk Larson
2009-03-14 02:47:23 ET

MWF 10:00

Tim Owens
2009-03-16 07:27:17 ET

MWF 9:00

Rachael Finkelstein
2009-03-16 15:59:09 ET

MWF 10:00

Trisha Gall
2009-03-16 19:05:34 ET

MWF 9

chelsey jansen
2009-03-17 16:07:37 ET

nams mwf 10

Sarah Norris
2009-03-19 16:49:29 ET

MWF 9 am

Cameron Tysor
2009-03-19 17:19:16 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Cassandra White
2009-03-19 19:46:10 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Adam Gehringer
2009-03-19 20:34:15 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Corey Whitley
2009-03-19 20:52:34 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Sara P
2009-03-19 20:57:09 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris MWF 9 am class
I never understood the outrage w/using American Indians as mascots. You generally pick a certain animal or person as a mascot because you admire and want to have the qualities of that mascot (although I don't know why someone would want to be, for example, a Benson Bunny), so I don't think it's being disrespectful to choose a "indians" or a certain tribe for a mascot. If anything, I think it's complimentary in most cases.

Megan Bystrom
2009-03-20 00:45:56 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Jon Green
2009-03-20 04:59:44 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Eric
2009-03-20 14:08:47 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Dan Tracy
2009-03-20 21:52:06 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Wesley Detweiler
2009-03-21 05:25:54 ET

NAMS MWF 10:00

I also do not support the legislation. Like the author states, I feel that education will make a more meaningful difference. Additionally, I think that we will be opening a flood gate for the PC crowed to try and pass legislation on every little thing that could possibly be found offensive by anyone, wasting time and tax dollars. This type of legislation is already running amok in our government, and we do not need to add to it. Someone is always going to feel offended. We do not have the capability to legislate all offensive material out of existence.

Katie Bohling
2009-03-21 20:48:22 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Nicholas Raitt
2009-03-23 00:03:12 ET

NAMS MWF 10:00 class

felicia
2009-03-23 01:09:51 ET

felicia Brooks mwf 9:00

Bridget Kelly
2009-03-23 03:42:22 ET

MWF 9:00 class

Constance Lewis
2009-03-23 13:28:09 ET

MWF 10am NAMS

josh tolliver-humpal
2009-03-23 14:59:08 ET

MWF 9 am native am. studies.

i think legislation should be passed to ban schools from using indians as mascots. though schools may argue they have a constitutional right to have such mascots under the guise of "free speech," i disagree. in my opinion, the use of an indian, or any other cultural or ethnic group, as a mascot constitutes "fighting words" which are not subject to free speech protections.

Matthew Deetz
2009-03-23 15:02:51 ET

MWF 10 am

Mark Gutierrez
2009-03-23 17:45:02 ET

Mark Gutierrez MWF 1:00PM

Mark Gutierrez
2009-03-23 17:46:11 ET

Mark Gutierrez MWF 1:00 PM

Caelan
2009-03-23 20:49:38 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Kathlyn
2009-03-23 21:09:25 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris MWF 9 am class

Margaret Schellen
2009-03-23 21:45:35 ET

Margaret Schellen NAMS MWF 9:00-10:00

Kristin Eaton
2009-03-23 22:41:55 ET

MWF 10 AM

Shawn Miller
2009-03-23 23:14:09 ET

MWF 9-9:50

Matthew Everson
2009-03-24 00:17:51 ET

MWF 10am

Jennifer Ponec
2009-03-24 01:26:32 ET

MWF 1pm Jennifer Ponec
It's too bad we still have to deal with these issues at this day and age.

CB
2009-03-24 04:05:13 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Katy Kramer
2009-03-24 20:09:35 ET

NAMS MWF 9:00

taylor branco
2009-03-24 22:57:25 ET

100 mwf

Danielle Von Tersch
2009-03-25 00:53:57 ET

MWF 9:00 AM

chris kelly
2009-03-25 01:08:51 ET

Brandon Bennett's Honors Credit NAMS MWF 1:00

Paula jakopovic
2009-03-25 01:40:58 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9AM Class

Kennedy Aikins
2009-03-25 01:43:32 ET

10.00am class

Brad Dinan
2009-03-25 02:10:10 ET

NAMS MWF 9:00

Lindsey Slocum
2009-03-25 02:42:27 ET

MWF 9:00

kristen seiber
2009-03-25 03:19:08 ET

MWF 9:00 class

Chad Anderson
2009-03-25 03:43:44 ET

MWF 9:00 am Native American Studies

Trung Pham
2009-03-25 13:16:17 ET

MWF 9:00 AM

Tyler Tallant
2009-03-25 15:13:48 ET

Tyler Tallant MWF 10:00 am class

Nate Wissink
2009-03-25 15:46:03 ET

Nate Wissink
MWF 10:00- 10:50

Amanda Kenkel
2009-03-25 15:50:46 ET

MWF 9am

Jesten Parrott
2009-03-25 15:57:43 ET

mwf 10:00 am

Kimberly Kirk
2009-03-25 16:03:50 ET

Kim Kirk MWF 1300

Patricia Harnisch
2009-03-25 16:31:17 ET

MWF 9:00

Matt Boro
2009-03-25 16:33:08 ET

MWF 10am-1050am

Teresa Stubbs
2009-03-25 17:29:55 ET

MWF 2:00pm

Teresa Stubbs
2009-03-25 17:31:26 ET

MWF 1:00pm (i messed the time up on the last one sorry)

Tadd Wood
2009-03-25 18:06:57 ET

Tadd Wood MWF 1-1:50

Jen Walcutt
2009-03-25 18:11:39 ET

MWF 1pm

Shuang Lu
2009-03-25 19:22:51 ET

MWF 1:00 P.m.

Weily Chung
2009-03-25 19:25:03 ET

MWF 1:00 PM

Kristine Niemann
2009-03-25 23:48:06 ET

MWF 1:00

Eric Graves
2009-03-26 01:03:00 ET

Eric Graves MWF 1:00

Aaron Leimser
2009-03-26 04:27:03 ET

MWF 9:00 am Nams class

2009-03-27 02:54:27 ET

MWF 10 A.M. Naive American Studies... Although it is impossible to legislate morality, it is incumbent upon society to deal with issues that pertain to the greater good. The outlawing of slavery is one example of this. Although legislation abolishing slavery was met with great resistance ultimately leading to civil war, few today will argue against these words, "all men are created equal and are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights: life, liberty. and the pursuit of happiness." Although I believe that any person has the right to their opinion, sometimes actions are required to awaken the public to injustices in our midst. I think that legislation banning the use of Indian mascots will continue to face resistance, however, I think if implemented, it will raise awareness. Indian mascots are terribly disrespectful and an insult. In the same way that racial slurs are offensive to people of different ethnic groups, this is offensive to many. While we cannot pass laws to prevent people from using racial slurs, we can and should diligently work to ensure that the public education system is not a partner and enabler of bigotry. It is our duty as citizens to fight injustice whenever we see it raise its ugly head. Bravo Wisconsin!

Justin Kirkland
2009-03-27 03:48:22 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Diana Lindloff
2009-03-27 04:16:59 ET

NAS MWF 10 AM

Lindsey Augustin
2009-03-27 14:32:54 ET

MWF 10:00AM NAMS

Laura Driscoll
2009-03-27 17:49:02 ET

MWF 1:00 class

Brandon Bennett
2009-03-28 06:30:30 ET

Brandon Bennett MWF 1-1:50pm

josh
2009-03-28 11:38:40 ET

Brandon Bennett's Honors Credit NAMS MWF 1:00

Cassandra West
2009-03-30 01:20:12 ET

9am Native American Studies

Kristen Peschel
2009-03-30 13:25:08 ET

MWF 9am class

Cale Deardorff
2009-03-30 13:42:25 ET

MWF 1 o Clock

Chelsea Alt
2009-03-30 13:42:43 ET

MWF 10am

Salem Al-Osaimi
2009-03-30 14:13:45 ET

MWF 9:00

mazen alragb
2009-03-30 14:18:23 ET

MWF
9:00 AM

Alli Hukill
2009-03-30 15:13:15 ET

MWF 9:00 am

Tuan Tran
2009-03-30 15:37:35 ET

mwf 10:00 am

Josh Armstrong
2009-03-30 16:00:57 ET

MWF 9:00 a.m. NAMS

Kathlene Sokol
2009-03-31 01:39:02 ET

NAMS 1100 (1000-1050AM)

Ericka Lippoldt
2009-03-31 01:45:26 ET

MWF class 10

Charlie
2009-04-01 00:50:58 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Mark Woodward
2009-04-01 04:54:52 ET

MWF 9 am. Jim Thorpe was an Indian. So was Standing Bear.

Kent Thorne
2009-04-01 13:12:24 ET

MWF 9 am

Anna Downard
2009-04-01 13:40:15 ET

MWF 9 AM

Claire Van Ormer
2009-04-03 13:58:07 ET

claire van ormer
native american studies
MWF 9AM

Brittany Hanssen
2009-04-03 14:11:49 ET

MWF @ 10:00 am

Thomas Kellogg
2009-04-03 17:25:33 ET

1:00 o'clock native american studies class.

Rebecca Ericksen
2009-04-04 00:46:20 ET

MWF @ 9 am

Erin Carnahan
2009-04-06 16:41:46 ET

MWF 1pm

Kimberly Buckley
2009-04-06 16:44:43 ET

MWF 1-1:50

Alyssa Brewer
2009-04-07 02:48:08 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Alison
2009-04-08 15:32:32 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

Caitlin Vandell
2009-04-08 18:26:34 ET

NAS 9 AM MWF Caitlin Vandell

Steven Frank
2009-04-08 21:49:04 ET

MWF 1:00-1:50

Kristin Clefisch
2009-04-10 03:25:22 ET

MWF 1:00

anja puc
2009-04-10 18:00:30 ET

mwf 1pm

Wenjun Zhang
2009-04-11 00:52:03 ET

MWF 10am class

Vicki Tysor
2009-04-11 02:09:23 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris. MWF 9 AM

Neal Bonacci
2009-04-11 19:02:48 ET

MWF 9:00

Christina Dhungana
2009-04-12 03:42:40 ET

MWF 10am class :)

Lindsey Slocum
2009-04-13 00:28:36 ET

MWF 9:00

Lindsey Slocum
2009-04-13 00:29:33 ET

MWF 9:00

Erin Claborn
2009-04-13 02:50:28 ET

MWF 10

beth haley
2009-04-13 13:20:42 ET

mwf 9:00

Armaun Karimzadeh
2009-04-13 15:34:05 ET

NAMS MWF 10-10:50 AM

Wing Chi Pun
2009-04-13 16:08:20 ET

MWF 1.00PM

Scott Humlicek
2009-04-13 16:12:52 ET

Honors Credit for Sarah Norris
MWF 9 am class

alex mckeone
2009-04-13 17:32:38 ET

alex mckeone NAMS MWF @ 1pm

Constance Lewis
2009-04-13 22:27:52 ET

Constance Lewis MWF 10am

Alyssa Roach
2009-04-16 19:03:34 ET

mwf 1:00

Dwight Gray
2009-04-20 16:13:20 ET

special topics in nams

Jason Moody
2009-04-27 05:22:18 ET

MWF 10:00

Cody Amend
2009-05-15 02:25:16 ET

TR 6:00-9:00 pm

Seth McKenzie
2009-05-15 21:44:13 ET

TR - Summer class 6-9pm

I know that being white, this situation does not pertain to me, but I feel it isn't proper to have Indian Mascots. People could say that Indians should be happy they are being represented in the community, but I feel that it has become too much of an issue in maintaining a genuine idea of a culture or group.

Holly Brink
2009-05-16 03:57:14 ET

TR NAMS summer class -- cool poll!

Bryanne Yosten
2009-05-22 01:45:53 ET

TR 6:00 Class

Carrie Scott
2009-05-24 03:13:46 ET

Summer TR class 6pm

Leslie Hepfner
2009-06-09 01:34:37 ET

Summer TR class 6-9:05

Melissa Whiteley
2009-06-23 20:47:31 ET

Summer TR class 6-9:05

Gary Michaels
2009-07-08 05:45:04 ET

The use of Indian mascots is not derogatory; even if it was, any attempt to legislate political correctness would be misguided and further erode basic rights. Mark Van Weelden SEEMED to make valid points, until you note that he doesn't know his history; he would do well to find out when the Americal civil war started (perhaps a Google search?), and when President Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation - and he would do well to note that the Proclamation applied ONLY to the states that were in rebellion, and did not free slaves in West Virginia, Kentucky, and/or Maryland. People who don't know how we got here shouldn't be trying to guide us into the future!

Linda Cheung
2009-09-18 17:26:50 ET

Fall 2009 TR 2:30-3:45

Brandon Boyd
2009-09-22 16:54:11 ET

Tue/Thurs 2:30

Laura Stevens
2009-10-02 18:49:15 ET

Tues./Thurs. 2:30

Natalie
2009-10-28 01:46:19 ET

"Brandon Bennett's Honors Credit NAMS MWF 1:00"

McKenzie Fullford
2009-10-31 21:51:17 ET

Cool

McKenzie Fullford
2009-10-31 21:53:05 ET

tues/Thurs 2:30-3:45



Leave a comment

Email Address *

Your email address will not be published. (We add your Gravatar icon if you have one)

Please enter a valid email address below.

Name *

Please enter your name below.

Your Website URL

Comment *

Maximum of 4000 chars. (0/4000)

Please enter a comment below.

(Fields marked * are mandatory)


Submit Comment
Spam controlled by Akismet

Poll Author

Honor Indians Institute is a non-profit institution created to provide educational class...

View My Previous Polls

My Website

Share Link

Use the link below to share this poll.

Embed This Poll

You can also place this poll on your website or blog as a widget. Simply copy and paste the code below into your HTML.

Alternatively, we now support oEmbed.