Answers Logo
Search


Who Should Play Jane in New Moon?



Dakota Fanning

Jodelle Ferland

Lucy Hale

Someone Else!

Vote

Share/Save/Bookmark
View The Results of This Poll



rss
35 Comments
dev
2009-01-29 14:58:31 ET

I picked some one else because I think there sould be some other actresses in the "house" lucy hale's for privleged, dakota's for the baby movies(yay I said it) and I have no idea who jodelle, but she doesn't look anything like Jane should, so what I was thinking is that you find someone for Jane, not privleged or baby movies(except Push thats an exception)adn find some one new, and talented!!!!!!!!!!!!!

dev
2009-01-29 15:02:05 ET

P.S. WHY DAKOTA, she doesn't even look like jane should, yes she's a good actress but for jane no, I mean some of you people haven't even heard of the books Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse and Breaking Dawn, and may soon to be Midnight Sun, till the movie so I don't think you guys should even be trying to pick who should be Jane, I mean come on...

Sunny
2009-01-29 15:11:48 ET

I think it should be Amanda Seyfriend from Big Love. She has this look in her face of distraught and beauty. When I look at her I think of a vampire.

Gina Lomem
2009-01-29 15:22:04 ET

I think that that my daughter would make a perfect Jane....

Arby23
2009-01-29 16:09:07 ET

If Summit Entertainment is looking for a Jane as young as Dakota Fanning, I think Annasophia Robb would be a better choice. She has a similar look, but a more menacing persona about her.

Samantha
2009-01-29 17:07:38 ET

I think Dakota Fanning would make an excellent Jane. Why you ask... In the books she is described as someone that is fiercely childlike. Her face is angelic and she has a childlike voice. She was changed in her early teen years. While reading the books Dakota fits perfectly what I saw in my mind. She is such an incredible actress and loves the books. I think she will make all the Twilight fans very proud of the job she'll do.

2009-01-29 17:26:29 ET

yo pienso que Dakota Fanning iría muy bien en este papel, aunque Jodelle Ferland también estaría bien, por su edad y por su pelo, pero la cara no le va a Jane, que es más bien más glamurosa que esa chiquilla que aparenta ser demasiado inocente para hacer el papel de una vampira asesina.

2009-01-29 17:30:19 ET

Sorry, I don't speak English

Elizabeth
2009-01-29 19:53:19 ET

I think that Dakota Fanning is the total wrong look and that Lucy Hale is too old and the other girl looks too young. I think that they need to go with a no name actress!

Yvette
2009-01-29 21:00:23 ET

Jodelle Ferland all the way!! she is already experienced at playing dark characters and she has the PERFECT look. Shes the right age, has the right angelic face, and the perfect haircolor(i think jane should have a short bob)

JODELLE FERLAND!

Mary Fig
2009-01-29 23:18:16 ET

Dakota Fanning is not right for the part of Jane. I think at least Lucy could do better as Jane but please not DAKOTA FANNING!!! She's not right for the twilight series movie!! LISTEN TO ME PEOPLE SHE'S NOT RIGHT FOR THE PART!!!!! I could probably do better than her (not that I'm an actress) but still!!! Please vote someone other than Dakota Fanning.

Roma
2009-01-29 23:35:59 ET

Lakoyea Mundo is playing the role of Jane of the Volturi :O)

jasmine
2009-01-30 00:26:26 ET

gemma ward

Gusto
2009-01-30 00:56:38 ET

i think someone else should play jane. i imagined her alot younger and more intimidating than those above choices. and for some odd reason, if not bald, near bald or something.

Juliet
2009-01-30 02:38:28 ET

I don't know. I don't like the idea of Dakota bieng Jane at all(she just plays in too many little kid movies, besides Push. she probably wouldn't be good at being the evil little vampire Jane is. Also She juss looks too young). I don't like Lucy either, she's just too old, and i have never even heard of her till now. I had never heard of Jodelle either but at least she was younger. they need someone younger than Lucy but older then Jodelle. She has to be sinister looking too. I agree with some of the others, that Amanda Seyfried and Annashopgia Robb should play Jane. They just look a little more rite 4 da part. the actress needs to look like a rebellious preteen. they also need to have experience in dark movies/shows/etc. I kno i wrote alot but o well dats my opinion.

tatianna
2009-01-30 03:17:51 ET

I think it should be Lucy because she's closer to the height of the possible Alecs.

Ro
2009-01-30 04:20:59 ET

Why not Jodelle Ferland? I think its great because she does have experience in menancing parts. For instance Silent Hill. She did an awesome job. And get this, she played in the messengers with Kristen Stewart.

Lindsay
2009-01-30 12:55:01 ET

um!..i think Lucy Hale should be Jane because seriously people..Dakota is just a kid and she looks too much like a kid..it would just make the part look really dumb and i've never heard of the other chick so.

Laura
2009-01-30 14:52:33 ET

¡ uyuyu ! ¡ esta empatadito ehm ! jajajajaja
al final no sé a quién prefiero , me mareais , tanto inglés . Algo cojo , pero tanto ...

Didi
2009-01-31 01:05:17 ET

i think jenna boyd or bella thorne should play jane

2009-01-31 16:48:54 ET

I Picked someone else because even though i'm a big fan of Dakota i don't think she has the look to play Jane and Jodelle sort of does. i send in my picture for that role and so did many other people who want this. I think it would be fair to give other people a chance and pick the best look for this character. (:

ANASTACIA
2009-02-01 20:55:52 ET

well, DEV or dev(the person under me) jodelle is the girl who played in silent hill(it is a okay movie, if you like creepy movies that were once games), but she plays a good creepy person....i voted for her but i also think dakota can do a good job. but jodelle can do a better job at playing some on creepy like jane(weird kids are cool i you do it right....i don't think dakota will pull jane all the way off....but i can wait until the movie come out)

ANASTACIA
2009-02-01 20:56:50 ET

opps! the very first person

Alice101
2009-02-02 01:05:14 ET

Are u guys crazy , really only Dakota can play Jane because all the other choices are dumb cause Lucy is too old. Joedell is too ulgly does anyone even agree wit me , if u do write back

Alice101
2009-02-02 01:08:31 ET

by the way dakota already got the role of Jane you know , this website is out of date

K
2009-02-06 14:38:33 ET

I think ANNA SOPHIA ROBB. She's perfect to play Jane

Valeria
2009-02-07 17:36:14 ET

There's no point of doing this as much as i want it to change it may not, Dakota Fanning gets closer and closer everyday to getting the part and she probrably already got it they just offered it to her. I reallly wanted this part but if i don't get it I want someone else to play Jane!!!!!

PS: I REALLY LIKE JODELLE FERLAND!!!!

someone
2009-02-08 01:31:46 ET

i think the girl that plays lessly from bridge to teribitha and the girl who chews alot of gum in charlie and the chocolate factory.

annasophia robb

steph
2009-02-23 04:29:24 ET

I always imagined Jane an african american woman in her 20's. in the book it did say the body under the cloak was darker than the cloak itself. I also think they she keep the cast new and fresh. they should find some new actors to throw in their instead of using people who are already known. I've hears of a girl named Lakoyea Mundo who is suppose to be really talented... but mainly they should try to keep all the cast members new so us fans wont know what to expect...

stacy wilbanks
2009-02-26 16:31:47 ET

I think that AnnaSophia Robb (bridge to terabithia) should play the role of Jane, she would do a really good job!

Kiki
2009-03-20 01:43:22 ET

I agree that someone NEW & TALENTED should play the role of Jane.Not someone already FAMOUS give someone else a chance to play the role.Please watch my videos @ youtube.com/redladyproductions.
Thanks

shelby
2009-04-07 22:40:14 ET

i think some else should because dakota cant pull the look off because she's all for the kid movies and the girl jodelle is from silent hill and well she cant really act (not to be mean) and the last girl well she looks to old to play jane so i think that someone like selenna gomez should because she can pull the look off,she can act,and shes young enough so i think she would be perfect.

Kaitelyn
2009-04-27 01:27:29 ET

Jodelle Ferland!!!definitly!!!She is better than all those losers up there. Jodelle should play jane because she has that adorableness to her and she looks the part.seriuosly she looks like she played in those movies about people suspecting witchcraft and she was going to be burned at the stake!! omg theres is so much more i could say about why Jodelle should be Jane in fact so much that it would be more than allowed!!! Jodelle Ferland For Jane!!!!

Kaitelyn
2009-04-27 01:32:20 ET

Oh yeah i forgot to mension that if you go to youtube and type into the searchbox "Jane- everything burns" or "watching everything burn-Jane" and you will see why Jodelle Is WAY BETTER than anyone else to play Jane in New Moon.!!!JODELLE FERLAND FOR JANE!!

Dakota
2009-06-22 23:32:22 ET

Dakota Fanning should play she perfect for NeW Moon ppl knock it off Dakota is play Jane Yesssssssssss!!!!!!!!!!!!! not some other stupid girl like JODELLE FERLAND and Sleana Gomez



Leave a comment

Email Address *

Your email address will not be published. (We add your Gravatar icon if you have one)

Please enter a valid email address below.

Name *

Please enter your name below.

Your Website URL

Comment *

Maximum of 4000 chars. (0/4000)

Please enter a comment below.

(Fields marked * are mandatory)


Submit Comment
Spam controlled by Akismet

Poll Author

Complete news & info about the sequel to Twilight, New Moon...

View My Previous Polls

My Website

Share Link

Use the link below to share this poll.

Embed This Poll

You can also place this poll on your website or blog as a widget. Simply copy and paste the code below into your HTML.

Alternatively, we now support oEmbed.