Answers Logo
Search


Top 3 Finalists - "Elvis Who?" Week (FINALE!) (Poll Closed)

Carlos Baez (Mexico) - 'Always Be My Baby' 32% (1,627 votes)

Kara Hess (USA) - 'My All' 28% (1,389 votes)

Rocky Heron (USA) - 'Vision of Love' 40% (2,022 votes)

Share/Save/Bookmark

Total Votes: 5,038



rss
38 Comments
Chris ^^
2008-12-29 17:24:31 ET

I love you carloz ^^

You are the best!!

Joi
2008-12-29 17:49:35 ET

Rocky FTW! I would actually like to hear a mash up of your version of VOL and Mariah's classic one - esp during the wailing at the end. I seriously think that your voices would blend really well. Kara, you have such a wonderful voice, and I love that you went all the way with My All. Carlos, you picked my favourite Mariah song - ever - so I'm going to be seriously biased, but when you belt out at the end - damn, boy, you can sing. All in all, I am happy that you guys made it to the final, cos you've all got what it takes. Good Luck to all, though Rocky gets my vote this time around as well.

2008-12-29 18:03:09 ET

Yes Carlos sing good but I'm so sad for Kara because I loved his cover of "You Got Me".

youssef
2008-12-29 19:02:13 ET

Carlos, Kara & Rocky. I love you gus! Great job...

fernando
2008-12-29 20:01:33 ET

Carlos yo voy por vos!....cantas muy bien
fram_2381@hotmail.com

Roly
2008-12-29 21:04:54 ET

Carlos' version sounds AWFULLY familiar to David Cook's version on Mariah night of American Idol this year... down to his vocals and notes that he emphasizes...(he has a nice voice though)... yeah..that final power note... totally David Cook's performance... (i'm just saying.)

Kara has such a pretty voice... i just wish she would have gotten rid of the echo effect; it takes away from the track... extra points for bravely doing My All a capella! :)... wish she would have belted it a little more at the end... (bonus for doing the musical breakdown with her voice... very pretty

Rocky -- was a decent arrangement... but was kinda boring...

Kara Hess
2008-12-29 22:57:02 ET

Thank you guys so much for your nice comments!!! I hope you like my rendition of My All, I really wanted to do " I Don't Wanna Cry " and I was working on a recording when my mac laptop crashed, all I had was this recording from years ago when my voice wasn't as strong as it is now, plus the software wasn't as good, I know I could've done better so I was hoping to God people would like it lol. Thank you so much!!!

yagirl809
2008-12-30 00:44:46 ET

rocky's voice is pure sex orgasm.

commentor
2008-12-30 01:35:13 ET

I thought the judges were way too nice to Rocky Heron. I thought the vocals were awful compared to Carlos and Kara, and it sounded like he was struggling with the belting toward the end.

Kara--props for doing it a capella.

Carlos--my pick. Beautiful arrangement and perfect belting at the end.

David F.
2008-12-30 05:01:41 ET

Kara, you have an amazing voice. I could listen to you all day! I'm voting for you only. All the time. Hope you win!

Mimi's revenge
2008-12-30 05:15:29 ET

Kara Hess has the talent to surpass Mariah

timo
2008-12-30 06:57:45 ET

Carlos- I LOVED the performance, u didnt do it EXACTLY like mariah but stayed true to the melody. I'm voting for you

Kara- i'm sorrry but i'm disappointed, the beginning was fine and then when u sang the first " i cant go ON" what was that run???? im sorry totally ruined the vibe for me... and i feel u ddnt stay true to the build-up of the song, ur ssecond and third choruses sound the same.

Rocky- YOU CAN'T CHANGE VISION OF LOVE!!!! before i pressed the play button i was hoping and praying that you ddnt change it.. the arrangement was EXTREMELY boring and repetitive, VOL is a dramatic song which needs dramatic vocals and the vocals were weak . u jst can't sing mariah n this is a singing competition.. the end was BUTCHERED... u do have a nice tone but this isnt the competition for you

for me the order in which i rote them is the order from best to worst : carlos, kara, rocky

faten
2008-12-30 08:16:33 ET

rocky's voice is pure sex orgasm!! lool

adrian135
2008-12-30 09:07:04 ET

¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡CARLOS IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!

HuHu CoCo Lee
2008-12-30 10:45:32 ET

CARLO U DID WELL AGAIN AGAIAN AND AGAIN IN THIS COMPETITION,
just abit flat overall on this ALWAYS BABY song.but i voted for u always since beginning u sung Mariah songs well with your own attitude and talents.

cookoo
2008-12-30 10:58:02 ET

TO ME EVERYBODY,
CARLO FORM MEXICO AND PETER FROM CZECH ARE BOTH BEST WITH THEIR OWN ELEMENTS SINGING STYLES AND TALENTS IN THIS MARIAH CAREY COMPETITION.

SO FOR ME ALWAYS ARE MY BABIES ARE

CARLOS MEXICO, AND PETR FROM CZECHOSLOVAKIA,
GOD BLESS YOU BOTH AND ALL IN THIS COMPETITION.AMEN,

FROM ASIA .

ChicoMC
2008-12-30 15:56:38 ET

Carlos, you sang the first song I hear from Mariah. “Always Be My Baby” and I love it!! You have my vote!! La mejor canción que pudiste escoger!! Hardcore Mariah Carey fan!! From Mexico!! n_n

kirsten
2008-12-30 18:11:27 ET

KARA! her voice is so pretty. plus My All is my favorite song in the whole world. go kara hope she wins!

salim
2008-12-30 21:47:08 ET

i luv Vision Of Love, the tribute to mariah's vibes, you're the winner

michel
2008-12-30 22:51:07 ET

i vote for carlos 'cause he's from mexico and he's cute and chicomc you are hot too!!!!!!

Leonardo
2008-12-31 02:58:22 ET

wwwoowww Carlos your voice sounds great, u hav my vote.

Rindy
2008-12-31 04:36:15 ET

Carlos did good. Kara did excellent on acapella, the runs were perfect, without no background music. Rocky I liked the way you changed the song, but I didnot like the ending. Well its only my opinion so don't take it personal. My vote goes to Kara the acapella performance was excellent. You all did a great job including the ones that didn't make it to the finale week. May God keep you and bless you as your soul proper and be in good health going into the New Year. Have a Happy New Year!

Bill
2008-12-31 05:16:58 ET

I love the Czech Republic, and the men in it! Petr's version of VOL rocked. ANy chance you want to movet to the US?

newmie
2008-12-31 13:13:01 ET

ROCKY is the best !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i luv his interpretation of the song
the voice
the vibes
the song
very good
he'll must be the winner

Kevin
2008-12-31 15:15:28 ET

Actually,Dzulfadzly Zammani's rendition of "Love Takes Time" was the best record this week.
And,the final 3 should be Abed Elamrani,Cidalia Castro and Dzulfadzly Zammani.But they all eliminated.

And,if I must choose,Carlos Baez is the best in Top 3.

Petya
2008-12-31 17:54:59 ET

my vote goes for Rocky!

Raphael
2009-01-01 01:40:30 ET

Congratulations all contestants for your courage and great talent Dzulfadzly great arrangement, nice. Petya nice rendition and I didn't know you had it in you to belt, nice job. Petr great attempt there were some nice moments... Now
Carlos gets my vote, overall he was great from beginning to end, and it was a fantastic job. Kara nice voice ... good luck and keep going. Rocky Love ya man... the song was nice and had some great moments. Glad you showed a different side of yourself vocally. Congrats all.

David F.
2009-01-01 05:55:10 ET

Dzulfadzly Zammani was actually the best with "Love Takes Time".... too bad he didnt make the top 3

Mummy's Choice
2009-01-01 16:51:54 ET

Love Takes Time is the winner of them all. Too bad he is not in the final 3 :(

Archie
2009-01-01 20:16:21 ET

Dzulfadzly Zammani did great job for "Love Takes Time" .He should be on top 3 ....Anyway congratulation to top 3 this week .

Carloz
2009-01-02 01:38:51 ET

Thank you for all your votes and support! I really feel winner just for be in the final. I hope my songs have liked you!!
Thank you so much!!

x-tina
2009-01-02 19:12:49 ET

i love you carlos!!!

ert
2009-01-05 19:30:48 ET

Carlos!!!!! you are the best!!!!!!!!! Felicidades!!!! todas tus interpretaciones estuvieron Fantasticas!!!!! bien por Mexico!!!!!!

2009-01-07 01:05:56 ET

carlos and Kara should win. i am voting for them

Tabatha Marie
2009-01-07 12:02:28 ET

Well i have listened a few times to all three finalist. I love Rocky's version of vision of love..so he got my vote..That as we all know was mariah's first single, and number 1. I felt he kept that song nice and simple, but at the same time it was chilling...I can actually hear this being mixed into a new hit....The guy can sing, and that was a gender bender on top of a "he did it his way" and WOW, does it sound beautiful~

Aryana
2009-01-07 18:46:28 ET

NOBODY has a sex orgasm voice except for Mariah Carey. There are other good singers out there but nobody compares to her.

Kara has a good voice. I like her singing. She should win.

2009-01-10 06:35:32 ET

You guys all did a great job!! Keep singing ;-)
Rocky you def won me over though- been following you since the beginning of the competition!
Good luck to all of you in your endeavors!!! Just keep smiling and keep singing!
Love Ya's Much
xoxoxox
-Tallon

2009-01-11 11:09:25 ET

What da f***???
I can't believe...
Why has an other win and not carlos???
His voice is incredible and unique , I can't believe you guys vote for another...
I'm crying =(
Much greetz , Ur Shawna!



Leave a comment

Email Address *

Your email address will not be published. (We add your Gravatar icon if you have one)

Please enter a valid email address below.

Name *

Please enter your name below.

Your Website URL

Comment *

Maximum of 4000 chars. (0/4000)

Please enter a comment below.

(Fields marked * are mandatory)


Submit Comment
Spam controlled by Akismet

Poll Author

The one-stop source for all things Mariah Carey...

View My Previous Polls

My Website

Share Link

Use the link below to share this poll.

Embed This Poll

You can also place this poll on your website or blog as a widget. Simply copy and paste the code below into your HTML.

Alternatively, we now support oEmbed.